opencode/CONTEXT.md

# OpenCode Session Runtime

OpenCode sessions preserve durable conversational history while assembling the runtime context an agent needs to act correctly in its current environment.

## Language

**System Context**:
The structured collection of contextual facts presented to the model as initial instructions and chronological updates.
_Avoid_: System prompt

**Session History**:
The projected chronological conversation selected for a provider turn after applying the active compaction and **Context Epoch** cutoffs.
_Avoid_: Session Context

**Context Source**:
One independently observed typed value within the **System Context**, represented by a stable key, JSON codec, infallible loader, pure baseline/update renderers, and an optional removal renderer for dynamic sources.
_Avoid_: Prompt fragment

**System Context Registry**:
The Location-scoped registry of ordered, scoped producers that contribute to the current **System Context**.

**Mid-Conversation System Message**:
A durable chronological instruction that tells the model the newly effective state of a changed **Context Source**.
_Avoid_: System update, system notification, raw text diff

**Context Epoch**:
The span during which one initially rendered **System Context** remains the immutable provider-cache baseline, ending at completed compaction, Session movement, or an incompatible context transition that requires a fresh baseline.

**Baseline System Context**:
The full **System Context** rendered at the start of a **Context Epoch**.
_Avoid_: Live system prompt

**Context Snapshot**:
The overwriteable model-hidden JSON state used to compare each **Context Source** with the value last admitted to a provider turn.

**Unavailable Context**:
An expected temporary inability to observe a **Context Source** value; the runtime retains its prior effective state and emits no update, or omits it until first successfully loaded.

**Safe Provider-Turn Boundary**:
The point immediately before a provider call, after durable input promotion and any required tool settlement, where context changes may be admitted chronologically.

**Admitted Prompt**:
A durable user input accepted into the Session inbox but not yet included in **Session History**.

**Prompt Promotion**:
The durable transition that removes an **Admitted Prompt** from pending input and appends its user message to **Session History**.

**Provider Turn**:
One request to a model provider and the response projected from that request.

**Session Drain**:
One process-local execution span that promotes eligible input and runs required **Provider Turns** until no immediate continuation remains. A Session Drain has no durable identity or transcript boundary.

**Model Tool Output**:
The bounded projection of a Core-executed tool result persisted in Session history and replayed to the model. A tool may shape this projection semantically, but the Tool Registry enforces the final size limit.

**Managed Tool Output File**:
A temporary file created under OpenCode's shared tool-output directory to retain complete output that was too large for Session history.

**Model Request Options**:
Provider-semantic model settings selected from the Catalog and active Session variant before the LLM protocol adapter encodes them for a provider request.
_Avoid_: Request body, wire options

**Generation Controls**:
Provider-neutral sampling and output controls, partitioned from provider semantics and compatibility wire fields when model metadata enters the Catalog.

**Native Continuation Metadata**:
Opaque protocol-shaped data attached to assistant content and required to continue that content natively with a compatible model, such as a reasoning signature or provider-hosted item identifier.

**PTY Environment**:
The host-supplied environment overlay applied by the server when creating a PTY, observed for the request Location and resolved PTY working directory.

**OpenCode Client**:
The generated Promise and Effect APIs derived from the public `HttpApi`; **Embedded OpenCode** shares the Effect API through an in-memory `HttpClient` against the same router and handlers.
_Avoid_: Remote client

**SDK Contract IR**:
The runtime-neutral compiled representation of the authoritative `HttpApi`, preserving encoded and decoded type projections plus transport metadata so independent SDK emitters can choose their public value model and runtime interpreter.

**Embedded OpenCode**:
A scoped in-process host that structurally extends the **OpenCode Client**, supplies an in-memory HTTP transport, and exposes additional same-process capabilities directly.
_Avoid_: Local implementation

**Page**:
A bounded ordered result containing `items` and opaque `previous` and `next` cursor links for navigating the same query in either direction.
_Avoid_: Response envelope

## Relationships

- A **System Context** is an opaque carrier composed from zero or more **Context Sources**.
- **Session History** contains projected conversational messages and admitted **Mid-Conversation System Messages**; the active **Baseline System Context** remains separate provider-request state.
- The **System Context Registry** uses stable-keyed scoped contributions to assemble the current **System Context**; contributor removal naturally removes its sources at the next **Safe Provider-Turn Boundary**.
- A changed **Context Source** may produce one **Mid-Conversation System Message** containing its newly effective state.
- A **Mid-Conversation System Message** persists the exact combined rendered text sent to the model.
- The current **Context Snapshot** advances atomically with the corresponding durable **Mid-Conversation System Message**.
- A **Context Snapshot** stores one codec-encoded JSON value and, for removable dynamic sources, a pre-rendered removal message per stable **Context Source** key.
- Changes from multiple **Context Sources** admitted at one safe boundary combine into one **Mid-Conversation System Message**.
- Context changes are sampled and admitted lazily at a **Safe Provider-Turn Boundary**, never pushed asynchronously when their source changes.
- At a **Safe Provider-Turn Boundary**, newly promoted user input or settled tool results precede any combined **Mid-Conversation System Message**.
- An **Admitted Prompt** is replayable pending input, not yet model-visible **Session History**.
- **Prompt Promotion** atomically consumes the pending inbox entry and appends its model-visible user message.
- Steering prompts promote at the next **Safe Provider-Turn Boundary** while the current **Session Drain** still requires continuation. Promoting any newly admitted user input resets the selected agent's provider-turn allowance; multiple prompts promoted at one boundary reset it once.
- A queued prompt does not promote while the current **Session Drain** requires continuation. The runner promotes one queued prompt when the Session would otherwise become idle, then reevaluates continuation before promoting another.
- A **Session Drain** is process-local coordination rather than a durable domain entity. Durable recovery must reason from prompts, projected history, provider attempts, and tool state rather than inventing an enclosing execution identity.
- The first provider turn renders the latest complete **Baseline System Context** and initializes its **Context Snapshot** without emitting a redundant **Mid-Conversation System Message**; unavailable initial context blocks the turn instead of persisting an incomplete baseline.
- Initial **System Context** preparation precedes the first durable input promotion so an unavailable baseline leaves that input pending and retryable; ordinary reconciliation remains after promotion.
- Compaction starts a new **Context Epoch** with a freshly rendered **Baseline System Context** and **Context Snapshot**; prior **Mid-Conversation System Messages** remain durable audit history but leave projected model history.
- A newly registered core or plugin-defined **Context Source** absent from the current snapshot emits its baseline rendering once at the next **Safe Provider-Turn Boundary**.
- **Context Source** keys are stable and namespaced; duplicate keys fail composition. `SystemContext.combine(...)` preserves caller order; the **System Context Registry** evaluates producers concurrently and combines them in stable contribution-key order so rendered context remains deterministic.
- Each **Context Source** loader returns one coherent typed value. `SystemContext.make(...)` hides that value type so differently typed sources compose uniformly. Its codec compares and stores that value; its pure renderers produce model-visible baseline, update, and removal text only when needed.
- `SystemContext.initialize(...)` observes a composed **System Context** once and produces a fresh **Baseline System Context** with its **Context Snapshot**.
- `SystemContext.reconcile(...)` observes a composed **System Context** once and returns exactly one next action: unchanged, updated, replacement ready, or replacement blocked.
- `SystemContext.replace(...)` renders a fresh generation after completed compaction or another baseline-replacing transition; it reports replacement blocked while previously admitted context is unavailable.
- **Unavailable Context** uses stale-while-revalidate semantics and is distinct from a successfully loaded absence, which may emit removal text.
- Ordinary **Context Source** loaders return values directly; loaders that intentionally use stale-while-revalidate may explicitly return **Unavailable Context**.
- Nested project instruction discovery after successful reads remains a follow-up; when implemented, discovered instructions must be admitted durably at the next **Safe Provider-Turn Boundary**.
- Location-scoped services naturally re-resolve effective context when a moved session next runs in its destination location.
- Moving a Session clears its active **Context Epoch**, so the destination must initialize a complete baseline before another prompt can promote.
- Instruction discovery, source identity, persistence, and file loading belong to the instruction service; the **System Context** abstraction only composes effectful producers and renders loaded values.
- The first instruction-service slice observes global and upward project `AGENTS.md` files as one ordered aggregate **Context Source** at each **Safe Provider-Turn Boundary**.
- Built-in and instruction context producers register through the **System Context Registry** with stable contribution keys. Plugin-defined context registration and hot-reload lifecycle remain a follow-up built on the same scoped registry seam.
- Selected-agent available-skill guidance is a **Context Source** composed with Location-wide registry sources immediately before Context Epoch admission. It lists only names and descriptions permitted for that agent; skill bodies and locations are exposed only through the permission-checked `skill` tool.
- The selected agent and model are sampled when a provider turn starts. Changes admitted after that boundary apply to the next provider turn and do not restart the current turn.
- Selected-agent available-skill guidance remains a **Context Source**. An agent switch that changes that guidance produces a **Mid-Conversation System Message** while preserving the current baseline.
- Local tool authorization and pending permission requests retain the effective agent of the provider turn that issued the call; a later agent switch cannot change that call's policy.
- Context source changes never wake idle sessions; the next naturally scheduled **Safe Provider-Turn Boundary** loads and compares current values lazily.
- Once admitted, a **Mid-Conversation System Message** remains durable even if the following provider attempt fails and is replayed unchanged on retry.
- **Mid-Conversation System Messages** remain durable Session-message history; normal user-facing transcript surfaces may hide them.
- The date **Context Source** initially preserves host-local calendar-date behavior; a configured user timezone may replace that default later.
- A **Context Epoch** begins with one immutable **Baseline System Context**.
- A **Baseline System Context** is stored durably and reused verbatim across process restarts within its **Context Epoch**.
- A **Baseline System Context** durably preserves the exact joined text used for the active provider-cache prefix.
- Completed compaction starts a new **Context Epoch** on the next provider attempt, folding the current complete **System Context** into a fresh baseline and removing earlier **Mid-Conversation System Messages** from active model history.
- A model/provider switch preserves the current **Context Epoch** and chronological conversation history; the new selection applies to the next provider turn.
- **Native Continuation Metadata** remains in durable history. Provider-turn projection includes it only for a successful exact originating provider/model match; failed turns and incompatible models omit opaque metadata, while non-empty visible reasoning lowers to ordinary assistant text after a model switch. This conservative relation may widen only when recorded provider tests establish compatibility.
- **Model Request Options** remain provider-semantic through Catalog resolution. The Session runner maps them into the LLM package's provider-option namespace; the selected protocol adapter alone owns provider wire encoding.
- **Generation Controls**, protocol-semantic **Model Request Options**, and compatibility request body fields are separate Catalog domains. A shared ingestion adapter partitions legacy and models.dev AI-SDK-shaped options before routing.
- The **PTY Environment** is a server concern rather than a Core PTY concern. PTY creation merges caller values, then the host overlay, then Core-forced terminal invariants such as `TERM` and `OPENCODE_TERMINAL`.
- Networked and **Embedded OpenCode** use the same **OpenCode Client** and preserve the full HTTP encoding, routing, middleware, and decoding boundary; only the `HttpClient` transport differs.
- The Effect-native network constructor obtains `HttpClient.HttpClient` from its environment so callers own transport selection, recording, tracing, retries, and tests. Convenience runtimes may provide a fetch transport separately.
- Creating **Embedded OpenCode** is scoped. Closing its owning Scope releases the in-process server resources, database resources, registrations, and fibers.
- **Embedded OpenCode** exposes shared client capabilities and embedded-only capabilities on one object; consumers do not navigate through a nested `.client` property.
- The beta **OpenCode Client** currently uses plural consumer-facing capability groups such as `sessions`; whether the stable Session namespace should instead be singular `session` must be settled before stabilization. Internal server identifiers do not implicitly define public client names.
- Server's concrete `HttpApi` is authoritative for shared **OpenCode Client** capabilities. Codegen compiles its Session group directly; the Effect runtime uses an equivalent Protocol-only projection so generated artifacts remain independent of Core and Server.
- SDK generation reflects the public `HttpApi` once into an **SDK Contract IR**. Promise and Effect emitters share endpoint structure and transport metadata without being required to expose identical public values: an emitter may select encoded wire types, decoded domain types, compile-time brands, runtime validation, and its own execution abstraction independently.
- The first Effect emitter is the rich projection: it exposes decoded Effect-native values, preserves brands and schema transformations, performs runtime schema decoding, and delegates transport interpretation to `HttpApiClient`. Lighter wire-shaped Effect output remains possible through another emitter policy rather than constraining the shared IR.
- The rich Effect emitter regenerates private executable schemas when the **SDK Contract IR** proves that their transport semantics can be reproduced exactly. Contracts with authoritative custom transformations use the import-based Effect emitter against a Protocol-only client projection whose generated transport output is tested against Server's concrete API; the Promise emitter still derives zero-Effect structural wire types from the same IR.
- `@opencode-ai/protocol` owns Session endpoint construction and middleware placement. Server supplies concrete middleware keys to produce the authoritative build-time API; the client projection supplies transport-only keys without importing Core or Server at runtime.
- The first Promise emitter targets the same clean domain-oriented method organization rather than Hey API source compatibility. It returns unwrapped values directly, rejects declared and infrastructure failures, and begins with minimal client-level transport configuration; result wrappers, interceptors, and legacy generated signatures are outside the initial surface.
- The first Promise emitter parses response syntax and trusts its generated structural types; it does not perform runtime structural validation. Malformed payload syntax fails, while a syntactically valid shape mismatch is not detected at the SDK boundary. Standalone validator generation remains an optional future emitter policy.
- Declared Promise-client failures retain their tagged structural wire values and have generated type guards. Consumers do not depend on generated `Error` subclass identity, preserving discrimination across package copies and realms while remaining structurally aligned with Effect domain errors.
- Promise-client infrastructure failures use one generated `ClientError` class with a structured reason such as transport failure, unexpected status, unsupported content type, or malformed response. Promise methods reject with either a tagged declared domain failure or `ClientError`, matching the Effect client's conceptual domain/infrastructure error division.
- Promise methods accept a separate optional per-call transport-options argument containing `AbortSignal` and header overrides. Cancellation and transport metadata do not enter the domain input object; broader interceptor and response-mode APIs remain deferred.
- Promise streaming methods return a lazy `AsyncIterable` directly rather than a Promise-wrapped stream object. Iteration opens the connection, `AbortSignal` cancels it, and ending iteration closes the underlying request; the Effect emitter analogously returns `Stream` directly.
- Promise SSE connection establishment, declared HTTP failures, and infrastructure failures occur during `AsyncIterable` iteration, beginning with its first `next()` call, rather than during synchronous method construction.
- Neither generated streaming runtime automatically reconnects after disconnection. Promise `AsyncIterable` and Effect `Stream` fail explicitly; live consumers refresh and resubscribe, while durable sequence-based resume remains explicit composition above the generated client.
- Promise client construction is synchronous and network-free. It requires `baseUrl`, defaults to `globalThis.fetch`, accepts client-level headers, and merges them with per-call header overrides.
- Effect client construction accepts an explicit `baseUrl` and obtains `HttpClient.HttpClient` from the Effect environment. It does not install fetch or duplicate per-call transport policy; callers transform/provide the client for headers, tracing, retries, recording, and tests, while fiber interruption owns cancellation.
- Promise and Effect emitters each own their generated public type modules. The **SDK Contract IR**, not a physically shared generated type package, is the common source; this permits zero-Effect wire types and rich decoded Effect types to evolve independently.
- Promise and Effect network clients ship from `@opencode-ai/client` behind isolated root and `/effect` exports. The root has no runtime path to Effect; `/effect` imports only Effect, Schema, and Protocol.
- The Effect-native scoped host belongs to `@opencode-ai/sdk-next`, which will assume the existing `@opencode-ai/sdk` name after legacy consumers migrate. Client remains network-only and SDK depends one-way on Client.
- SDK executes Server's assembled `HttpRouter` in memory. It opens no listener and performs no network I/O, while preserving Server routing, middleware, codecs, handlers, and errors.
- The Effect Client and SDK re-export their decoded datatype facade from Schema so callers do not depend on internal package locations or Core's versioned names.
- A capability intended for both networked and **Embedded OpenCode** belongs in the authoritative public `HttpApi`; embedded-only same-process capabilities extend **Embedded OpenCode** separately.
- `sessions.events({ sessionID, after })` is a public durable Session event stream. It verifies the Session, replays durable events after the optional aggregate sequence, continues with newly committed durable events, excludes live-only fragments, and is transported as SSE in both networked and embedded modes.
- `events.subscribe()` is a distinct public instance-wide live stream for Session and non-Session activity. It has no replay guarantee and includes connection, heartbeat, and instance-disposal lifecycle events; consumers recover from disconnection by refreshing authoritative state.
- A Session ID is not an optional filter on `events.subscribe()`: instance-wide live events and durable Session events have different schemas, replay guarantees, cursors, lifecycle events, and failure behavior.
- The initial common OpenCode Client does not expose server-global event aggregation. `events.subscribe()` is bounded to the connected OpenCode instance or workspace; any future cross-instance administrative stream requires a separately designed API.
- `events.subscribe()` does not automatically reconnect after transport loss. The live-only stream fails with `ClientError`; consumers refresh authoritative state before explicitly opening a new subscription because events missed during disconnection cannot be replayed.
- `sessions.events({ sessionID, after })` returns the generated HTTP client's cold durable event stream and does not build reconnection policy into the endpoint or client constructor. Transport loss fails the stream with `ClientError`. Callers may compose an explicit resuming stream above it by retaining the last observed durable sequence and opening a new subscription with `after`; any reusable resume helper remains a separate API design question.
- The stable `sessions.list(...)` design returns a **Page** in both networked and **Embedded OpenCode**; embedded execution does not define a separate unbounded array-returning list operation. The beta client currently preserves the existing HTTP `{ data, cursor }` envelope until emitter-level Page projection is implemented.
- Session list cursors are opaque branded values carrying continuation query and ordering state. Consumers pass them back unchanged and do not inspect storage anchors or encoded filter fields.
- A Session list continuation accepts only its opaque cursor. Scope, filters, ordering, and page size are fixed by the initial query and carried by that cursor.
- `sessions.messages(...)` returns a **Page** and uses the same cursor discipline as `sessions.list(...)`: the initial request supplies `sessionID`, ordering, and page size; continuation supplies `sessionID` plus only an opaque branded message cursor carrying ordering, page size, direction, and message anchor. Using a cursor with another Session is invalid.
- `sessions.message({ sessionID, messageID })` is a required resource lookup. An unknown Session fails with `SessionNotFoundError`; a known Session with an absent or differently owned message fails with `MessageNotFoundError` without disclosing cross-Session ownership. Absence is not represented as `undefined` across the public HTTP boundary.
- `sessions.interrupt({ sessionID })` first verifies that the durable Session exists, failing with `SessionNotFoundError` otherwise. For a known Session, interruption is idempotent: idle, already-settled, or locally unowned execution is a no-op.
- `sessions.active()` snapshots the current process's foreground Session drain registry as a record of Session IDs to `{ type: "running" }`. Missing IDs are inactive; background subagents and tasks do not make their parent Session active, and process restart clears the registry.
- `sessions.context({ sessionID })` preserves the existing message-only operation. It returns projected conversational messages selected as Session context; it does not include or represent the complete provider request context, whose baseline system context and other contributions remain separate.
- **Open question**: Should a future, separately named operation expose the complete provider request context, including baseline system context, selected source contributions, and context-epoch metadata?
- `sessions.prompt(...)` exposes `resume?: boolean`. Omitting it preserves durable admission followed by an advisory execution wake; `resume: false` requests durable admit-only behavior.
- The public operation remains `sessions.prompt(...)`; `SessionInput.admit` is the internal primitive, while the public `Admission` result and `resume` option express its durable admission semantics.
- `sessions.create(...)` accepts an optional `location`. Omission resolves through the connected OpenCode instance's default or current location; an explicit value selects a known location. Networked and embedded transports use the same handler semantics.
- `sessions.switchAgent({ sessionID, agent })` is part of the common client alongside `sessions.switchModel(...)`. It affects subsequent Session activity and fails with `SessionNotFoundError` for an unknown Session.
- The **Embedded OpenCode** Layer delegates to the same scoped creation path; it does not define a second implementation.
- A **PTY Environment** adapter observes plugins in the request Location while passing the resolved PTY working directory to the hook; standalone servers use an empty adapter.
- A **Mid-Conversation System Message** lowers to the provider's native chronological instruction role when supported and to a wrapped chronological fallback otherwise.
- When the effective aggregate instruction set changes, its **Mid-Conversation System Message** includes the complete current ordered set and supersedes the prior aggregate value; when no ambient instructions remain, the message states that previously loaded instructions no longer apply.
- Ambient project instruction discovery honors `OPENCODE_DISABLE_PROJECT_CONFIG`; global instructions remain eligible.
- Oversized textual **Model Tool Output** retains a bounded preview in Session history while its complete text moves to managed tool-output storage. Arbitrary structured-result size is a separate concern.
- One tool settlement receives one aggregate textual limit, using the configured maximum lines or UTF-8 bytes, whichever is reached first. The limit is provider-independent; token pressure belongs to context assembly and compaction.
- Generic truncation preserves the beginning and end of textual output. Tools may apply a more meaningful strategy before the Tool Registry enforces the final limit.
- A truncated **Model Tool Output** identifies its complete text both in the bounded model-visible preview and as a typed managed output path. Managed output paths do not modify the tool's validated structured result.
- A **Managed Tool Output File** is temporary and may expire after its retention period. The bounded **Model Tool Output**, not the file, is the durable replayable record.
- Failure to retain a **Managed Tool Output File** does not change a successful tool operation into a failed one. The Session records an explicitly lossy bounded output without a path, while operators receive diagnostics for the storage failure.
- Once a tool operation succeeds, bounding its **Model Tool Output** and publishing its one durable settlement form an interruption-safe completion region. Raw oversized success is never published before a later correction.
- When a structured-only result would exceed the **Model Tool Output** limit, its validated structured value remains unchanged for Session consumers while model replay uses a bounded textual JSON preview and optional managed output path.
- Existing tool-managed output paths survive generic bounding. A fallback file retains exactly the complete projected text received by the Tool Registry and never claims to reconstruct output already discarded by tool-specific shaping.
- **Managed Tool Output Files** use globally unique names in one shared flat directory. Their absolute paths are readable and searchable by ordinary tools; other absolute paths remain outside Location-scoped filesystem authority.
- Provider-executed tool results remain provider-native transcript facts outside generic Tool Registry bounding. Their context control requires provider-aware pruning or compaction because some providers require exact structured round-trip payloads.

## Client contract architecture

Semantic values that mean the same thing internally and publicly live in the lightweight Schema leaf. Core consumes Schema for domain behavior; Protocol composes Schema values into paths, payloads, envelopes, errors, cursors, and streams; Server imports both, hosts Protocol's exact groups, and owns protocol/domain adaptation. The root Promise client remains zero-Effect, `/effect` depends on Effect plus Schema and Protocol, and `@opencode-ai/sdk-next` composes the scoped in-process host above Client, Core, and Server.

Shared public records are plain objects declared with `Schema.Struct`. A same-name inferred interface gives object records readable TypeScript signatures without constructors, prototypes, or nominal identity; unions retain explicit type aliases.

Before stabilizing the client API:

- Keep additional public schemas in Schema and additional network groups in Protocol; neither package may transitively load databases, Drizzle, Session execution, providers, watchers, native modules, or WASM.
- Keep concrete Location middleware keys in Server while Protocol owns their placement. Client projections may supply transport-only keys, but must prove generated equivalence with Server's concrete API.
- Project the existing list response envelope to the stable client **Page** shape and enforce separate initial-query and cursor-continuation inputs without changing the hosted V2 wire contract.
- Settle the stable consumer namespace (`session` versus the current beta `sessions`) and use an explicit codegen annotation if the consumer name should differ from the server group identifier.
- Preserve V2 route paths, operation IDs, codecs, errors, middleware behavior, and OpenAPI output while making this change.
- Preserve browser-safe `@opencode-ai/client` and `@opencode-ai/client/effect` bundles through import-boundary tests.
- Define embedded-host placement before supporting multiple hosts over one database. Hosts that share durable Session storage must also share process-local Session execution coordination, or each host must receive isolated storage explicitly.
- Keep an embedded request scope alive until any streamed response body finishes. The initial non-streaming Session surface does not exercise this lifetime boundary; Session and instance event streams must do so before joining the embedded client.

## Example dialogue

> **Dev:** "The date changed while the session was active. Should the **Mid-Conversation System Message** say what the old date was?"
> **Domain expert:** "No. Emit the newly effective date so the agent can act on the current **System Context**."

## Flagged ambiguities

- Legacy `experimental.chat.system.transform` can mutate the assembled baseline system prompt arbitrarily, but V2 plugins do not yet expose an equivalent hook. Decide separately whether to port it, replace dynamic uses with plugin-defined **Context Sources**, or narrow its semantics.