Add files via upload

ProblemMap/Atlas/troubleshooting-atlas-router-v1.txt

@@ -0,0 +1,983 @@
+AI_NOTE_START
+
+FORMAT_NOTICE:
+machine-readable first
+for human-readable explanations and full documentation, use the GitHub WFGY repository
+
+ORIGIN:
+standalone routing pack derived from the GitHub WFGY repository and Problem Map 3.0 Troubleshooting Atlas
+
+ASSET_NAME:
+troubleshooting-atlas-router-v1
+
+ROLE:
+route-first pack for troubleshooting and failure classification
+
+PRIMARY_USE:
+- classify case
+- identify earliest decisive failure
+- choose highest honest resolution
+- suggest first repair direction
+- warn against likely misrepair
+
+NOT_FULL_REPLACEMENT_FOR:
+- full Atlas
+- full Casebook
+- full Adapter
+- full repair engine
+- autonomous agent
+- full root-cause closure
+
+CORE_IDEA:
+route first
+repair second
+structural failure over topic similarity
+earliest decisive failure over downstream consequence
+honest coarse fit over decorative precision
+
+REQUIRED_OUTPUT:
+- primary_family
+- secondary_family
+- why_primary_not_secondary
+- broken_invariant
+- best_current_fit
+- first_fix_direction
+- misrepair_risk
+- confidence
+- evidence_sufficiency
+
+OPTIONAL_OUTPUT:
+- need_more_evidence
+
+VALUE_SPACE:
+confidence = high | medium | low
+evidence_sufficiency = sufficient | partial | weak
+secondary_family = family_name | none
+best_current_fit = family-level | node-level | unresolved_subtype | no-fit
+
+CORE_RULES:
+1. route first; repair second
+2. use structural failure, not topic words
+3. prefer earliest decisive failure
+4. use highest honest resolution only
+5. if evidence is thin, stay coarse
+6. secondary_family is not decoration
+7. give first repair direction only
+8. confidence must follow evidence
+9. structural evidence beats vocabulary cue
+10. if Atlas plausibly covers case at family-level, do not jump to no-fit
+
+AI_NOTE_END
+
+ROUTER_NAME:
+Troubleshooting Atlas Router v1
+
+ROUTER_ONE_LINE:
+standalone route-first TXT pack for Problem Map 3.0 Troubleshooting Atlas
+
+SECTION_1_CORE_CONTRACT
+
+TASK:
+reduce wrong-family routing
+reduce wrong first-fix choice
+preserve honest fit resolution
+
+SUCCESS_CONDITION:
+- primary_family honest
+- broken_invariant useful
+- best_current_fit not decorative
+- first_fix_direction structural
+- misrepair_risk real
+
+DO_NOT:
+- solve whole case
+- fake precision
+- use ambiguity as escape hatch
+- give long speculative repair plans
+- classify from rhetoric alone
+
+QUICK_ROUTE_WORKFLOW:
+1. normalize_case
+2. choose_primary_family
+3. test_nearest_competing_family
+4. set_fit_resolution
+5. set_first_fix_and_misrepair
+
+SECTION_2_CASE_INTAKE_NORMALIZATION
+
+NORMALIZE_CASE_FIRST:
+convert raw case into structural failure description before routing
+
+SEPARATE:
+- symptom vs earliest_decisive_failure
+- missing_visibility vs actual_boundary_failure
+- truth_anchor_loss vs carrier_distortion
+- continuity_loss vs execution_skeleton_failure
+- danger_wording vs real_drift_erosion_fragmentation_overshoot
+- symbolic_vocabulary vs true_representation_failure
+- runtime_stress vs true_execution_closure_failure
+
+INTAKE_QUESTIONS:
+Q1: what fails first
+Q2: what structural evidence supports that reading
+Q3: what neighbor may absorb case too early
+Q4: what missing evidence would change the cut
+
+SECTION_3_SECONDARY_FAMILY_DISCIPLINE
+
+USE_SECONDARY_ONLY_IF:
+- neighboring pressure changes reading
+- neighboring pressure matters for boundary explanation
+- neighboring pressure matters for first-fix warning
+
+DO_NOT_USE_SECONDARY_IF:
+- rhetorical sophistication only
+- main reading already clean
+- neighboring pressure is speculative and non-material
+
+DEFAULT:
+if neighboring pressure weak -> secondary_family: none
+
+RULE:
+one honest primary > vague primary + decorative secondary
+
+SECTION_4_TIE_BREAK_PRINCIPLES
+
+TIE_BREAKS:
+1. earliest decisive failure > later consequence
+2. visible carrier failure > progression diagnosis when carrier clearly broken
+3. true anchor loss > formal resemblance in world/evidence/target mismatch
+4. visibility deficit > higher-order policy interpretation when path still not exposed
+5. continuity-thread failure > execution-skeleton speculation unless operational dependency failure is explicit
+6. explicit operational closure failure > generic continuity language when bridge/readiness/ordering/liveness evidence is concrete
+7. real drift/erosion/fragmentation/overshoot > danger wording
+8. if two readings remain plausible under thin evidence -> stay coarse
+
+SECTION_5_CONFIDENCE_CALIBRATION
+
+CONFIDENCE_HIGH_IF:
+- primary cut explicit
+- nearest competing family explicitly rejected
+- broken invariant clear
+- first_fix stable under current evidence
+- evidence_sufficiency = sufficient
+
+CONFIDENCE_MEDIUM_IF:
+- primary plausible
+- nearest competing family still live
+or
+- subtype unstable while family stable
+or
+- evidence_sufficiency = partial
+
+CONFIDENCE_LOW_IF:
+- only coarse family plausible
+or
+- decisive evidence weak
+or
+- competing family unresolved
+or
+- first_fix still provisional
+
+CONFIDENCE_ALIGNMENT_RULE:
+confidence must not exceed evidence_sufficiency
+
+SECTION_6_SEVEN_FAMILY_OPERATIONAL_CORE
+
+F1_NAME:
+Grounding & Evidence Integrity
+F1_WHAT_FAILS_FIRST:
+loss of alignment with evidence anchors, truth anchors, world anchors, referents, or semantic targets
+F1_BROKEN_INVARIANT:
+anchor_to_claim_coupling_broken
+F1_NOT:
+- not primarily carrier failure
+- not chosen only because answer seems vague or wrong
+- not chosen from truth/meaning/realism vocabulary alone
+F1_CONFUSION:
+- F7
+- F5
+F1_TRIGGER:
+earliest = evidence mismatch | target mismatch | referent drift | world-target miss | truth-anchor loss
+F1_FIRST_FIX_PATTERN:
+- re-grounding
+- evidence verification
+- world-anchor check
+- target-reference audit
+- proxy_vs_target separation
+F1_MISREPAIR:
+rewrite style or prompt tone before anchor restoration
+F1_MIN_EVIDENCE:
+need anchor/evidence/referent/target/world mismatch signal
+
+F2_NAME:
+Reasoning & Progression Integrity
+F2_WHAT_FAILS_FIRST:
+inferential path, decomposition path, recursive path, or collapse-recovery path fails before grounding, continuity, or carrier fidelity becomes decisive
+F2_BROKEN_INVARIANT:
+progression_continuity_broken
+F2_NOT:
+- not primarily descriptor/carrier failure
+- not chosen from logic/reasoning/math vocabulary alone
+F2_CONFUSION:
+- F7
+F2_TRIGGER:
+carrier usable enough, but inferential path stalls, collapses, loops, fragments, or cannot recover
+F2_FIRST_FIX_PATTERN:
+- decomposition reset
+- interpretation checkpoint
+- recursive horizon fencing
+- recovery scaffold
+- progression guard
+F2_MISREPAIR:
+redesign carrier when actual first failure is progression path
+F2_MIN_EVIDENCE:
+need inferential path failure, progression break, recursive instability, or collapse-recovery signal
+
+F3_NAME:
+State & Continuity Integrity
+F3_WHAT_FAILS_FIRST:
+memory, role, ownership, continuity thread, or multi-agent interaction thread loses stability before contract or execution closure becomes primary
+F3_BROKEN_INVARIANT:
+state_continuity_broken
+F3_NOT:
+- not primarily ordering/readiness/bridge/liveness failure
+- not chosen from memory/identity/agent vocabulary alone
+F3_CONFUSION:
+- F4
+- F6
+F3_TRIGGER:
+earliest = role continuity | ownership continuity | memory persistence | persistence drift | interaction-thread instability
+F3_FIRST_FIX_PATTERN:
+- continuity restoration
+- role fencing
+- persistence guard
+- provenance tracing
+- interaction stabilization
+F3_MISREPAIR:
+add more instructions without restoring continuity infrastructure
+F3_MIN_EVIDENCE:
+need persistence break, role contamination, ownership discontinuity, continuity drift, or interaction-thread instability
+
+F4_NAME:
+Execution & Contract Integrity
+F4_WHAT_FAILS_FIRST:
+execution skeleton, ordering, readiness, bridge, liveness, closure path, or rule-to-action contract fails before continuity or visibility becomes primary
+F4_BROKEN_INVARIANT:
+execution_skeleton_closure_broken
+F4_NOT:
+- not primarily role/memory continuity problem
+- not chosen only because runtime fails
+F4_CONFUSION:
+- F3
+- F5
+- F6
+F4_TRIGGER:
+earliest = ordering | readiness | bridge integrity | protocol closure | enforcement closure | deadlock | liveness
+F4_FIRST_FIX_PATTERN:
+- readiness audit
+- ordering validation
+- bridge check
+- liveness watchdog
+- closure-path trace
+- rule-to-action restoration
+F4_MISREPAIR:
+improve reasoning or prompt quality before fixing runtime skeleton
+F4_MIN_EVIDENCE:
+need execution dependency failure, readiness failure, deadlock, bridge failure, closure failure, or liveness collapse
+
+F5_NAME:
+Observability & Diagnosability Integrity
+F5_WHAT_FAILS_FIRST:
+system cannot expose, trace, audit, diagnose, or anticipate relevant failure structure before deeper intervention is honest
+F5_BROKEN_INVARIANT:
+failure_path_visibility_broken
+F5_NOT:
+- not automatically correct because case sounds abstract or dangerous
+- not substitute for true boundary failure
+- not substitute for true grounding failure
+F5_CONFUSION:
+- F6
+- F4
+- F1
+F5_TRIGGER:
+earliest = missing path visibility | missing coherence visibility | missing fragility signature | missing audit route
+F5_FIRST_FIX_PATTERN:
+- observability insertion
+- trace exposure
+- audit-route uplift
+- coherence visibility support
+- warning horizon extension
+F5_MISREPAIR:
+launch higher-order intervention before exposing the relevant path
+F5_MIN_EVIDENCE:
+need missing traceability, missing auditability, missing coherence exposure, or warning blindness first
+
+F6_NAME:
+Boundary & Safety Integrity
+F6_WHAT_FAILS_FIRST:
+goal, control, incentive, collective, or regime boundary erodes before visibility deficit or execution closure becomes primary
+F6_BROKEN_INVARIANT:
+boundary_integrity_broken
+F6_NOT:
+- not automatically correct because case sounds dangerous, political, aligned, risky, or safety-related
+- not chosen from rhetoric alone
+F6_CONFUSION:
+- F5
+- F4
+- F3
+F6_TRIGGER:
+earliest = real drift | erosion | fragmentation | capture | overshoot | unstable boundary crossing
+F6_FIRST_FIX_PATTERN:
+- alignment guard
+- control-path audit
+- incentive rebalancing
+- safe-corridor monitoring
+- damping and stabilization
+F6_MISREPAIR:
+improve observability only while boundary itself is already drifting
+F6_MIN_EVIDENCE:
+need real drift/erosion/fragmentation/capture/overshoot/unstable boundary-crossing evidence; danger wording alone insufficient
+
+F7_NAME:
+Representation & Localization Integrity
+F7_WHAT_FAILS_FIRST:
+structural carrier, symbolic shell, descriptor, layout, local anchor, or formal container fails before reasoning progression or external anchoring becomes decisive
+F7_BROKEN_INVARIANT:
+representation_container_fidelity_broken
+F7_NOT:
+- not automatically correct from symbols/logic/OCR/JSON/schema vocabulary alone
+- not chosen from vocabulary alone
+F7_CONFUSION:
+- F1
+- F2
+- F5
+F7_TRIGGER:
+earliest = carrier distortion | descriptor inadequacy | local anchoring failure | structural shell failure
+F7_FIRST_FIX_PATTERN:
+- descriptor audit
+- structural preservation
+- local anchor repair
+- layout validation
+- formal adequacy check
+F7_MISREPAIR:
+repair reasoning chain or grounding surface while carrier remains untrustworthy
+F7_MIN_EVIDENCE:
+need carrier distortion, descriptor inadequacy, symbolic collapse, local anchor break, or structural shell failure
+
+SECTION_7_MINIMAL_EVIDENCE_CHECKLIST
+
+FAMILY_MIN_EVIDENCE_SUMMARY:
+F1 -> anchor/evidence/referent/target/world mismatch
+F2 -> inferential path failure/progression break/recursive instability
+F3 -> continuity drift/persistence break/role contamination/ownership break
+F4 -> readiness/ordering/bridge/liveness/closure/enforcement failure
+F5 -> missing traceability/auditability/coherence exposure/warning visibility
+F6 -> real drift/erosion/fragmentation/overshoot/capture/unstable boundary crossing
+F7 -> carrier distortion/descriptor inadequacy/structural shell/local anchor failure
+
+THIN_EVIDENCE_GATE:
+if evidence thin and family plausible -> family-level
+if subtype unstable -> unresolved_subtype
+if competing family unresolved -> lower confidence, do not force node-level
+if Atlas plausibly covers case -> prefer need_more_evidence over no-fit
+
+SECTION_8_BOUNDARY_DECISION_MATRIX
+
+B_F1_F7:
+A=F1
+B=F7
+A_if=truth_anchor_loss|evidence_mismatch|referent_drift|world_target_failure first
+B_if=carrier_distortion|descriptor_failure|structural_shell_failure|local_anchor_failure first
+not_A_if=symbolic_or_synthetic_appearance_only_without_anchor_evidence
+not_B_if=representation_words_only_without_carrier_evidence
+conf_A=explicit_anchor_mismatch
+conf_B=explicit_carrier_failure
+tie=anchor_break>carrier_if_external_mismatch_explicit_else_coarse
+
+B_F5_F6:
+A=F5
+B=F6
+A_if=missing_visibility|missing_traceability|missing_auditability|warning_blindness|uninspectable_coherence first
+B_if=drift|erosion|capture|fragmentation|overshoot|unstable_boundary_crossing first
+not_A_if=path_already_visible_and_boundary_already_failed
+not_B_if=danger_wording_only_without_real_boundary_evidence
+conf_A=explicit_observability_or_audit_deficit
+conf_B=explicit_drift_erosion_fragmentation_overshoot
+tie=unexposed_path>F5; visible_boundary_failure>F6; otherwise coarse
+
+B_F3_F4:
+A=F3
+B=F4
+A_if=memory|role|ownership|continuity_thread|interaction_thread failure first
+B_if=readiness|ordering|bridge|liveness|execution_closure|rule_to_action failure first
+not_A_if=coordination_loss_is_really_execution_dependency_failure
+not_B_if=runtime_failure_is_really_continuity_thread_loss
+conf_A=explicit_continuity_evidence
+conf_B=explicit_operational_dependency_evidence
+tie=continuity_first>F3; execution_skeleton_first>F4; otherwise coarse
+
+B_F2_F7:
+A=F2
+B=F7
+A_if=carrier_usable_but_inferential_path_breaks
+B_if=formal_or_symbolic_carrier_inadequate_before_reasoning_can_be_trusted
+not_A_if=logic_or_math_words_only_without_path_evidence
+not_B_if=formal_appearance_only_without_carrier_break
+conf_A=explicit_progression_failure
+conf_B=explicit_carrier_or_descriptor_failure
+tie=broken_carrier>F7; broken_progression_under_usable_carrier>F2; otherwise coarse
+
+B_F1_F5:
+A=F1
+B=F5
+A_if=explicit_anchor_failure_first
+B_if=path_too_opaque_to_establish_anchor_failure
+not_A_if=answer_looks_wrong_but_anchor_break_not_exposed
+not_B_if=anchor_mismatch_already_explicit
+conf_A=anchor_evidence
+conf_B=audit_or_visibility_deficit
+tie=visible_anchor_break>F1; opaque_path>F5
+
+B_F4_F5:
+A=F4
+B=F5
+A_if=execution_skeleton_break_explicit
+B_if=too_opaque_to_determine_execution_break
+not_A_if=execution_failure_only_suspected
+not_B_if=execution_dependency_failure_already_exposed
+conf_A=concrete_execution_structure_evidence
+conf_B=real_missing_traceability
+tie=opaque_execution_path>F5; explicit_skeleton_break>F4
+
+B_F3_F6:
+A=F3
+B=F6
+A_if=actor|role|ownership|interaction|persistence continuity fails first
+B_if=boundary_drift|fragmentation|capture|unsafe_transition fails first
+not_A_if=actor_instability_language_but_real_issue_is_collective_boundary_erosion
+not_B_if=danger_collective_language_but_real_issue_is_continuity
+conf_A=continuity_evidence
+conf_B=boundary_evidence
+tie=continuity_first>F3; boundary_drift_first>F6
+
+B_F4_F6:
+A=F4
+B=F6
+A_if=rule_to_action|bridge|enforcement|protocol|operational_order breakdown first
+B_if=boundary_erosion|legitimacy_drift|fragmentation|overshoot first
+not_A_if=operational_stress_but_real_issue_is_boundary_failure
+not_B_if=institutional_or_political_language_but_real_issue_is_closure_failure
+conf_A=operational_closure_evidence
+conf_B=real_boundary_or_regime_evidence
+tie=operational_closure_first>F4; boundary_regime_failure_first>F6
+
+SECTION_9_RESOLUTION_DISCIPLINE
+
+FAMILY_LEVEL:
+use_when=family structurally supported but node/subtree evidence too thin
+note=valid_outcome_not_weakness
+
+NODE_LEVEL:
+use_when=direct_structural_evidence_for_specific_node_exists
+do_not_use_when=node_name_only_sounds_close
+
+UNRESOLVED_SUBTYPE:
+use_when=family clear but subtype selection premature
+note=better_than_forced_node_name
+
+NEED_MORE_EVIDENCE:
+use_when=Atlas plausibly covers case but decisive routing depends on missing evidence
+do_not_use_when=missing signal would not materially change route
+
+NO_FIT:
+use_when=real_structural_mismatch_with_Atlas
+do_not_use_when=family-level plausible fit still exists
+
+DOWNGRADE_RULES:
+- weak_node_evidence -> family-level
+- competing_plausible_families_under_thin_evidence -> coarse
+- missing_subtype_signal -> unresolved_subtype
+- confidence_outpaces_evidence -> lower_confidence_then_lower_resolution
+
+SECTION_10_FIRST_FIX_AND_MISREPAIR
+
+FIRST_FIX_RULE:
+- structural_not_cosmetic
+- address_broken_invariant_first
+- not_full_repair_script
+- plausible_under_current_evidence
+- first_move_only
+
+MISREPAIR_RULE:
+- name_tempting_wrong_first_move
+- explain_why_tempting
+- explain_why_it_misses_earliest_decisive_failure
+
+PAIRING_FORMAT:
+first_fix_direction = short_structural_move
+misrepair_risk = tempting_wrong_move | why_tempting | why_wrong
+
+SECTION_11_AMBIGUOUS_NOFIT_DISCIPLINE
+
+AMBIGUOUS:
+rare
+use_only_if=two_or_more_family_readings_remain_genuinely_unresolved_after_structural_analysis
+do_not_use_if=case_is_only_complex_or_high_abstract
+
+NO_FIT:
+rarer
+use_only_if=real_structural_miss
+do_not_use_if=family-level plausibility remains
+
+COARSE_ROUTING_PREFERENCE:
+if honest_family_level_fit_exists -> prefer_coarse_fit_over_decorative_uncertainty
+
+ASK_MORE_EVIDENCE_RULE:
+request_more_evidence_only_if=missing_signal_would_materially_change_route_or_fit_resolution
+
+SECTION_12_EXEMPLAR_COVERAGE_INDEX
+
+EX1=F1|F5
+EX2=F7|F2
+EX3=F5|F4
+EX4=F4|none
+EX5=F3|F4
+EX6=F6|F5
+EX7=F1|F7
+EX8=F5|F6
+EX9=F4|F7
+EX10=F3|F5
+EX11=F5|F6|thin_evidence
+EX12=F1|F7|abstract_anchor
+
+SECTION_13_GOLD_MINI_EXEMPLARS
+
+EX1_F1_GROUNDING_FIRST:
+case=answer cites retrieved chunks but chosen chunks do not support actual claim
+primary=F1
+secondary=F5
+why=evidence-anchor mismatch arrives before opacity
+broken_invariant=evidence_anchor_integrity_broken
+first_fix=re_grounding|evidence_verification
+misrepair=add_explanation_before_anchor_restoration
+
+EX2_F7_CONTAINER_FIRST:
+case=formal descriptor cannot preserve required reasoning structure
+primary=F7
+secondary=F2
+why=carrier fails before progression can be trusted
+broken_invariant=formal_descriptor_fidelity_broken
+first_fix=descriptor_audit|formal_adequacy_validation
+misrepair=improve_reasoning_steps_while_carrier_broken
+
+EX3_F5_OBSERVABILITY_FIRST:
+case=system fails repeatedly but logs do not expose failure path
+primary=F5
+secondary=F4
+why=path invisibility arrives before confirmed execution closure failure
+broken_invariant=failure_path_visibility_broken
+first_fix=trace_exposure|observability_insertion
+misrepair=rewrite_execution_logic_before_path_exposure
+
+EX4_F4_EXECUTION_FIRST:
+case=workflow stalls because readiness dependencies and bridge conditions never satisfied
+primary=F4
+secondary=none
+why=execution skeleton collapse arrives before reasoning weakness
+broken_invariant=readiness_and_closure_integrity_broken
+first_fix=ordering_validation|bridge_checks
+misrepair=improve_prompts_before_fixing_dependencies
+
+EX5_F3_CONTINUITY_FIRST:
+case=across turns system loses role ownership and stable interaction thread
+primary=F3
+secondary=F4
+why=continuity thread loss arrives before bridge closure failure
+broken_invariant=interaction_thread_continuity_broken
+first_fix=role_fencing|continuity_restoration
+misrepair=stronger_instructions_without_restoring_persistence
+
+EX6_F6_BOUNDARY_FIRST:
+case=control system observable but incentive drift pushes unsafe behavior
+primary=F6
+secondary=F5
+why=boundary drift arrives before missing visibility
+broken_invariant=control_boundary_integrity_broken
+first_fix=control_path_audit|incentive_rebalancing
+misrepair=add_observability_only_while_boundary_drifting
+
+EX7_F1_F7_SYNTHETIC:
+case=model in synthetic environment fails to extract stable truth-like anchors
+primary=F1
+secondary=F7
+why=synthetic truth-anchor grounding fails before shell collapse
+broken_invariant=synthetic_truth_anchor_grounding_broken
+first_fix=truth_like_anchor_validation|referent_extraction_audit
+misrepair=repair_surface_structure_before_anchor_layer
+
+EX8_F5_F6_HIGH_ABSTRACT:
+case=value_probability_knowledge system unstable but coherence structure still not inspectable
+primary=F5
+secondary=F6
+why=missing coherence visibility arrives before proven overshoot
+broken_invariant=coherence_profile_visibility_broken
+first_fix=meaning_profile_tracing|coherence_visibility_uplift
+misrepair=jump_to_boundary_intervention_without_structure_exposure
+
+EX9_F4_F7_TOOL_SCHEMA:
+case=tool call fails because schema/contract mismatch breaks executable invocation path
+primary=F4
+secondary=F7
+why=operational closure fails first; schema matters because it blocks callable contract
+broken_invariant=execution_contract_closure_broken
+first_fix=contract_validation|tool_schema_to_runtime_check
+misrepair=rewriting_reasoning_without_fixing_call_contract
+
+EX10_F3_F5_SESSION_HANDOFF:
+case=multi-turn assistant loses prior role/thread after session handoff and logs remain sparse
+primary=F3
+secondary=F5
+why=continuity thread fails first; observability pressure is real but secondary
+broken_invariant=session_continuity_broken
+first_fix=persistence_guard|handoff_trace_restore
+misrepair=adding_policy_text_before_restoring_state_thread
+
+EX11_THIN_EVIDENCE_MULTI_FAMILY:
+case=case sounds high-risk and unstable but evidence only shows partial opacity plus vague drift language
+primary=F5
+secondary=F6
+why=visibility deficit is supported; boundary failure is not explicit
+broken_invariant=partial_failure_path_visibility_broken
+first_fix=trace_exposure|coherence_probe
+misrepair=forcing_boundary_stabilization_under_thin_evidence
+
+EX12_ABSTRACT_ANCHOR_CASE:
+case=formal philosophical output looks symbolic but actual failure is mismatch with target referent
+primary=F1
+secondary=F7
+why=anchor mismatch arrives first; formal appearance is misleading
+broken_invariant=target_reference_coupling_broken
+first_fix=referent_audit|target_anchor_check
+misrepair=repairing_symbolic_style_before_target_alignment
+
+SECTION_14_GOLD_OUTPUTS
+
+OUT1_HIGH:
+primary_family=F1
+secondary_family=F5
+why_primary_not_secondary=decisive failure is evidence-anchor mismatch; opacity exists but does not arrive first
+broken_invariant=evidence_anchor_integrity_broken
+best_current_fit=node-level:F1_N01 Retrieval Anchor Drift
+first_fix_direction=re_grounding|chunk_to_target_trace
+misrepair_risk=explanation_or_style_refinement_before_anchor_restoration
+confidence=high
+evidence_sufficiency=sufficient
+
+OUT2_MEDIUM:
+primary_family=F5
+secondary_family=F6
+why_primary_not_secondary=coherence visibility bottleneck appears first; boundary pressure may emerge later
+broken_invariant=coherence_path_visibility_broken
+best_current_fit=family-level
+first_fix_direction=coherence_visibility_uplift|audit_route_exposure
+misrepair_risk=boundary_stabilization_before_structure_is_inspectable
+confidence=medium
+evidence_sufficiency=partial
+
+OUT3_LOW_NEED_MORE:
+primary_family=F4
+secondary_family=F3
+why_primary_not_secondary=execution skeleton stress visible but continuity loss remains plausible under thin trace
+broken_invariant=possible_closure_path_instability
+best_current_fit=family-level
+first_fix_direction=collect_more_readiness_ordering_continuity_evidence
+misrepair_risk=forcing_bridge_repair_interpretation_too_early
+confidence=low
+evidence_sufficiency=weak
+need_more_evidence=clarify_whether_ordering_bridge_failure_or_continuity_thread_loss_arrives_first
+
+OUT4_FAMILY_ONLY:
+primary_family=F7
+secondary_family=F2
+why_primary_not_secondary=carrier stress is clear but subtype evidence insufficient
+broken_invariant=representation_carrier_integrity_weakened
+best_current_fit=family-level
+first_fix_direction=descriptor_and_carrier_audit
+misrepair_risk=progression_first_reading_before_carrier_check
+confidence=medium
+evidence_sufficiency=partial
+
+OUT5_TWO_FAMILY_COMPETITION:
+primary_family=F5
+secondary_family=F6
+why_primary_not_secondary=both diagnosability pressure and boundary pressure exist, but current evidence supports opacity first
+broken_invariant=auditability_and_coherence_visibility_bottleneck
+best_current_fit=family-level
+first_fix_direction=trace_exposure|coherence_visibility_uplift
+misrepair_risk=using_F6_stabilization_before_boundary_failure_is_explicit
+confidence=low
+evidence_sufficiency=partial
+
+OUT6_HIGH_RISK_SOUNDING_THIN:
+primary_family=F6
+secondary_family=F5
+why_primary_not_secondary=control drift evidence is explicit, but observability pressure remains unresolved
+broken_invariant=control_boundary_stability_degraded
+best_current_fit=unresolved_subtype
+first_fix_direction=control_path_audit|incentive_boundary_check
+misrepair_risk=treating_case_as_pure_visibility_problem_after_drift_is_already_visible
+confidence=medium
+evidence_sufficiency=partial
+
+SECTION_15_OVERLAY_SHORT_RULE
+
+OBS:
+use_if=visibility|traceability|auditability|interpretability pressure dominates
+type=overlay_not_primary_family
+
+SEC:
+use_if=boundary_abuse|adversarial_manipulation|exploitative_misuse|attack_pressure clear
+type=overlay_not_primary_family
+
+LOC:
+use_if=layout|OCR|placement|spatial_text_anchor|local_structural_alignment failure dominates
+type=overlay_not_primary_family
+
+MAIN_FAMILY_FIRST:
+decide_main_family_first
+overlay_refines_reading
+overlay_does_not_replace_routing
+overlay_does_not_become_primary_family
+
+SECTION_16_FIT_CANDIDATE_REGISTRY
+
+F1_FITS:
+stable_enough=Retrieval Anchor Drift|Semantic Grounding Mismatch|Synthetic Truth Grounding|OOD World Grounding Failure|Train-Deploy Distribution Grounding Gap
+use_with_caution=Policy-to-World Grounding Failure
+family_level_only_if_thin=general_grounding_failure|evidence_anchor_mismatch|target_reference_drift
+do_not_overreach=no_specific_grounding_subtype_without_clear_anchor_target_referent_world_evidence
+
+F2_FITS:
+stable_enough=Interpretation Collapse|Long-Chain Reasoning Continuity Failure|Collapse-Recovery Failure
+use_with_caution=Recursive Horizon Instability|Symbolic Progression Breakdown|Philosophical Recursion Pressure
+family_level_only_if_thin=reasoning_progression_failure|recursive_instability|decomposition_failure
+do_not_overreach=no_named_reasoning_subtype_without_visible_inferential_pattern
+
+F3_FITS:
+stable_enough=Memory Continuity Failure|Role / Ownership Contamination|Viable State-Space Collapse|Multi-Agent Continuity Instability
+use_with_caution=Ownership Continuity Break|Interaction-Thread Drift
+family_level_only_if_thin=continuity_failure|persistence_break|role_thread_instability
+do_not_overreach=no_specific_continuity_subtype_without_isolation_of_role_ownership_memory_interaction
+
+F4_FITS:
+stable_enough=Bootstrap Ordering Failure|Deployment Deadlock|Pre-Readiness Execution Failure|Bridge Integrity Failure|Cross-Layer Liveness Degradation
+use_with_caution=Institutional Enforcement Drift|Rule-to-Action Closure Failure|Accountability Path Thinning|Fallback Realism Gap
+family_level_only_if_thin=execution_skeleton_failure|closure_path_failure|operational_dependency_collapse
+do_not_overreach=no_detailed_F4_fit_if_ordering_bridge_liveness_enforcement_only_guessed_from_symptom
+
+F5_FITS:
+stable_enough=Failure Path Opacity|Oversight Coverage Failure|Coherence Observability Deficit|Meaning-Profile Auditability Failure
+use_with_caution=Scalable Interpretability Pressure|Early Warning Deficit|Fragility Signature Blindness|Regime-Shift Warning Delay
+family_level_only_if_thin=diagnosability_failure|auditability_failure|warning_visibility_failure
+do_not_overreach=no_specific_observability_subtype_without_identifiable_missing_path_or_warning_deficit
+
+F6_FITS:
+stable_enough=Alignment Boundary Drift|Control Boundary Erosion|Incentive Boundary Distortion|Incentive Misalignment Drift|Polarization Incentive Amplification
+use_with_caution=Collective Boundary Drift|Collective Legitimacy Erosion|Coordination-Boundary Fragmentation|Collective Regime Overshoot
+family_level_only_if_thin=boundary_drift|control_drift|incentive_erosion|regime_instability
+do_not_overreach=no_specific_F6_subtype_without_real_drift_erosion_fragmentation_capture_overshoot_evidence
+
+F7_FITS:
+stable_enough=Symbolic Representation Fidelity Failure|Logic Descriptor Fidelity Failure|Formal Container Adequacy Failure|Localization and Layout Anchoring Failure
+use_with_caution=Explanation Fidelity Distortion|Synthetic Structure Fidelity Failure|Hierarchical Composition Drift|Constraint-Skeleton Distortion
+family_level_only_if_thin=representation_failure|descriptor_failure|carrier_distortion|structural_shell_instability
+do_not_overreach=no_specific_F7_subtype_without_visible_carrier_descriptor_layout_shell_failure
+
+SECTION_17_AUDIT_APPENDIX
+
+AUDIT_STRUCTURE:
+- product_identity_and_scope
+- core_routing_contract
+- case_intake_normalization
+- secondary_family_discipline
+- tie_break_principles
+- confidence_calibration
+- seven_family_operational_core
+- minimal_evidence_checklist
+- boundary_decision_matrix
+- resolution_discipline
+- first_fix_and_misrepair
+- ambiguous_no_fit_discipline
+- exemplar_coverage_index
+- gold_mini_exemplars
+- gold_outputs
+- overlay_rule
+- fit_candidate_registry
+- audit_appendix
+- pressure_tests
+- release_gate
+- freeze_note
+
+AUDIT_FAMILY_OPERATIONALIZATION:
+each_family_must_have=
+what_fails_first|
+broken_invariant|
+what_this_family_is_not|
+confusion_family|
+boundary_trigger|
+first_fix_pattern|
+misrepair_trap|
+minimum_evidence
+
+AUDIT_BOUNDARY_COVERAGE:
+required_boundaries=
+F1/F7|F5/F6|F3/F4|F2/F7|F1/F5|F4/F5|F3/F6|F4/F6
+each_boundary_must_have=
+choose_A|
+choose_B|
+not_A_too_early|
+not_B_too_early|
+evidence_threshold|
+default_tie
+
+AUDIT_RESOLUTION_COVERAGE:
+must_define=
+family-level|
+node-level|
+unresolved_subtype|
+need_more_evidence|
+no-fit|
+downgrade_rules|
+thin_evidence_gate
+
+AUDIT_MISREPAIR_COVERAGE:
+every_family_must_define_at_least_one_common_misrepair_trap
+
+AUDIT_OUTPUT_COVERAGE:
+required_fields_supported_by_examples=
+primary_family|
+secondary_family|
+why_primary_not_secondary|
+broken_invariant|
+best_current_fit|
+first_fix_direction|
+misrepair_risk|
+confidence|
+evidence_sufficiency
+
+SECTION_18_NO_LAZINESS_AUDIT
+
+FAIL_IF_TOPIC_SHORTCUT:
+- safety_words_auto_F6
+- OCR_logic_schema_words_auto_F7
+- memory_words_auto_F3
+- execution_words_auto_F4
+- abstract_language_auto_F5
+
+FAIL_IF_DECORATIVE_SECONDARY:
+secondary_family_used_only_to_sound_intelligent
+
+FAIL_IF_DECORATIVE_NODE_FIT:
+node_level_from_thematic_resemblance_without_direct_structural_evidence
+
+FAIL_IF_AMBIGUITY_ESCAPE:
+ambiguous_or_no_fit_used_when_honest_coarse_fit_exists
+
+FAIL_IF_COSMETIC_FIX_FIRST:
+first_fix_direction_drifted_to_style_prompt_surface_cleanup_before_broken_invariant
+
+SECTION_19_PRESSURE_TESTS
+
+TEST_1_GROUNDING_VS_CONTAINER:
+can_router_distinguish_external_anchor_loss_from_structural_carrier_failure_without_collapsing_both_into_F1_or_F7
+
+TEST_2_OBSERVABILITY_VS_BOUNDARY:
+can_router_avoid_choosing_F6_too_early_when_first_bottleneck_is_missing_visibility_or_coherence_exposure
+
+TEST_3_CONTINUITY_VS_EXECUTION:
+can_router_distinguish_role_ownership_persistence_drift_from_ordering_readiness_bridge_closure_failure
+
+TEST_4_FORMAL_LOOKING_BUT_GROUNDING_FIRST:
+can_router_avoid_overreading_F7_when_case_looks_formal_but_first_real_failure_is_truth_anchor_mismatch
+
+TEST_5_HIGH_ABSTRACT_BUT_ROUTABLE:
+can_router_avoid_ambiguous_or_no_fit_too_early_on_high_abstract_cases_still_plausibly_routable_at_family_level
+
+TEST_6_MODE_STABILITY:
+same_case_under_strict_teaching_repair_first_compact_should_preserve_same_primary_family_and_same_broken_invariant_reading
+explanation_depth_may_change
+primary_routing_should_not_drift_casually
+
+SECTION_20_RELEASE_GATE
+
+PASS_IF:
+1. all_7_families_operationalized
+2. all_8_required_boundaries_decisionized
+3. best_current_fit_resolution_rules_explicit
+4. fit_candidate_registry_present
+5. first_fix_and_misrepair_paired
+6. at_least_12_mini_exemplars_present
+7. at_least_6_gold_outputs_present
+8. overlay_rule_present
+9. audit_appendix_present
+10. pressure_tests_present
+
+FAIL_IF:
+- family_names_without_operational_definitions
+- decorative_node_fit_common
+- F6_or_F7_absorb_cases_from_topic_words_alone
+- ambiguous_or_no_fit_used_as_uncertainty_shortcut
+- first_fix_direction_cosmetic
+- output_fields_exist_without_exemplar_support
+
+FREEZE_STATEMENT:
+if_pass_and_not_fail -> troubleshooting-atlas-router-v1 may be treated as operational_freeze and first_formal_standalone_routing_pack
+
+SECTION_21_FREEZE_NOTE
+
+WHAT_THIS_ROUTER_IS:
+first formal standalone route-first TXT pack derived from Problem Map 3.0 Troubleshooting Atlas
+
+WHAT_IT_DOES:
+- classify failures
+- cut key family boundaries
+- identify broken invariants
+- choose honest fit resolution
+- suggest first repair direction
+- reduce likely misrepair
+
+WHAT_IT_DOES_NOT_REPLACE:
+- full Atlas
+- full Casebook
+- full Adapter
+- full repair layer
+- deeper WFGY exploration
+
+FROZEN_ENOUGH_NOW:
+- product identity
+- TXT delivery form
+- route-first output contract
+- seven-family quick map
+- high-value boundary layer
+- confidence and evidence discipline
+- first-fix restraint
+- exemplar-backed routing surface
+
+PATCHABLE_LATER:
+- wording compression
+- stronger exemplars
+- broader domain coverage
+- stronger deployment variants
+- tighter future patch alignment
+
+UNSUPPORTED_SCOPE_NOTE:
+current exemplar coverage is strongest in troubleshooting-adjacent AI failures, retrieval-like grounding, control, multi-agent continuity, execution closure, and diagnosability-heavy cases
+broader generation-first, dialogue-native, and code-synthesis-native cases remain patchable expansion zones
+
+CROSS_LLM_VALIDATION_HOOK:
+empirical cross-LLM validation remains patchable
+future evaluation may compare routing stability, fit honesty, and first-fix quality across multiple model families
+
+OFFICIAL_ONE_LINE:
+Troubleshooting Atlas Router v1 is the first formal route-first TXT pack derived from Problem Map 3.0 Troubleshooting Atlas. It helps AI systems classify failures, cut key family boundaries, identify broken invariants, and suggest the first repair direction without overclaiming full repair closure.